Garth's Warning: For the Stars, Winning the 'Close Ones' Is the Real Test
**Core Answer:** Melbourne Stars' senior pacer Kim Garth has identified their recurring inability to win close T20 games as the main obstacle to becoming WBBL|12 contenders, citing a 15-run loss to Perth Scorchers and her own risky reverse-sweep dismissal as examples. **Key Facts:** - Stars have won just 1 of their first 3 matches in WBBL|12. - Garth admitted the team has struggled to 'get over the line' for the past few years. - She was dismissed lbw attempting a reverse sweep against Alana King in a 15-run defeat. - Garth said the shot cost her sleep, highlighting the pressure within the team. - The article is a promotional piece tied to the club podcast 'The Scoop' on cricket.com.au. **Source Attribution:** cricket.com.au, WBBL|12 coverage | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com **Related Q&A:** Q: What is Melbourne Stars' win-loss record in WBBL|12 so far? A: They have won 1 match out of 3, according to cricket.com.au. Q: Who dismissed Kim Garth with a reverse sweep? A: Alana King trapped her lbw with a leg-spinner, as reported by cricket.com.au. Q: What is the main issue Garth identifies for the Stars? A: Their recurring failure to win close matches, a pattern she says has persisted for years, per cricsultan.com analysis.
There is a strange silence in the Melbourne Stars dressing room these days. After three matches in WBBL|12, they have just one win. The margin of defeat was 15 runs against Perth Scorchers. It wasn't a last-ball thriller, but Kim Garth, one of the team's senior fast bowlers, calls it a 'close game'. And that's where a story begins, not just of this season but of the past few years.
Speaking on the club podcast 'The Scoop', Garth openly admitted that the team often gets into strong positions but loses matches in the final overs. Her statement cannot be taken lightly, as it's not just the frustration of one loss but an acknowledgment of a pattern. In a league like the WBBL, where the last five overs decide the outcome, winning 'close games' is the real skill. The Stars lack that skill, according to Garth.
In T20 cricket, a 15-run margin doesn't seem huge, but it symbolises the psychological wall that has built up within the team. This wall isn't just about bowling or batting but about decision-making. Garth herself lost her wicket playing a reverse sweep against leg-spinner Alana King, trapped lbw. It was a risky shot for a lower-order batter, especially when the team needed runs. Garth later admitted that the shot cost her sleep. This isn't just a mistake but an example of a premeditated wrong decision under pressure.
This is the root of the Stars' problem. They reach a good position in the match, but when the pressure mounts, their decisions falter. This is visible not just in batting but in bowling too. Garth herself said the team has been grappling with this issue for the past few years. It's a structural weakness, not just of one season.
In the WBBL, where every team has talent, the difference often lies in having a 'finisher' — someone who can turn the match on its head in the final overs. The Stars don't seem to have an established finisher. Garth didn't mention this directly, but her statement hints at it. The team has good bowling, but there's no explosiveness in the middle order to bridge a 15-20 run gap.
With just one win in the first three matches of this season, the Stars are in the lower half of the table. The headline 'how the Stars can become WBBL contenders' itself suggests they are not contenders yet. It's a diagnosis, not a celebration.
Garth's biggest strength is that she doesn't blame others for the loss. She owned her shot as a mistake and also acknowledged the team's collective weakness. This is the mark of a senior player who wants to build a culture of accountability in the dressing room. But will this culture win matches? This question is important because Garth also said she 'lost sleep' over the shot. This means the pressure is deep within the team, and that's not a good sign.
But there's a catch. Is the Stars' real problem mentality or selection strategy? Garth's statement suggests the team gets into good positions but doesn't know how to win. This is typically a symptom of a lack of a finisher. If the team had a batter who could win matches in the final overs, this situation might not exist. But attributing it solely to one player's absence and linking it to mentality would be wrong. It's possible the team's strategy itself isn't right under pressure.
The early-season data is very limited — just three matches. But Garth's reference to 'the past few years' gives this problem a permanent character. It's not just about this year. The Stars have been losing 'close games' consistently, and this is creating an image that's hard to shake.
And this is where a contradiction arises. The team has talent but not results. A senior player like Garth saying the team 'often puts itself in strong positions but loses' shows the problem is more strategic than technical. In the WBBL, where every team has limited resources, the difference often comes from small decisions made under pressure. Garth's reverse sweep is an example of that.
But can a whole team's strategy be judged by one shot? No. But it symbolises the mentality prevalent in the team. Garth admitted her mistake, but the question is whether the rest of the team will do the same. If yes, there's room for improvement. If not, this will just be another story of a loss.

There's another aspect to this article, not related to cricket but equally important. It's published on Cricket Australia's official platform and is also a promotion for the club's podcast. This means the intensity of criticism of the team may be limited. It's not independent analysis but a piece written from a soft angle. Therefore, when reading Garth's statement, one should remember that it's a voice from within the team, not from an external lens.
So can the Stars become contenders this season? The answer depends on whether they can learn to win 'close games' in the next few matches. If they do, it'll be more than a win — it'll be a change in mentality. If not, it'll be another season where talent deceived results.
For Garth, this is not just a shot but a lesson. She said she regrets playing the reverse sweep in that situation. This question is for every player under pressure. In cricket, sometimes the bravest shot is the biggest mistake. And the team must understand that winning requires not just talent but making the right decision at the right time.
If the Stars want to become contenders this season, they must erase the fear of 'close losses' from their dressing room. Garth's statement acknowledges this fear, but acknowledging alone isn't enough. Now it remains to be seen whether the team can turn this fear into courage.
Finally, a question for every cricket lover: Do the Stars have a 'finisher' who can win matches in the final over? If not, should they look for such a player in the next transfer window? This question is important because in the WBBL, every team has limited resources, and selecting the right player is the key to success. Garth's words are not just a warning but an invitation — the team must recognise its weaknesses and overcome them.
